While both white gold and sterling silver share a similar silvery sheen, they are quite different in terms of composition, appearance, durability and cost. Continue reading to discover what sets these two metals apart and to help you decide which might be best for you.
White gold is an alloy, which means it’s made by mixing pure gold with other metals. Pure gold is naturally yellow, so to create white gold, it’s combined with metals like zinc, nickel or copper. The result is a white metal that still retains the underlying qualities of gold, albeit with a much lighter, cooler hue. In most cases, white gold jewelry is plated with rhodium, a highly reflective metal from the platinum group, which gives it an even brighter white appearance.
White gold has a slightly warmer, richer coloration compared to silver. The presence of gold in the alloy adds a subtle yellowish undertone that silver does not have. Rhodium plating makes it more reflective and gives it a glossy, mirror-like finish. However, the rhodium plating on white gold may fade with time, which will cause the piece to lose some of its brilliance. This can be easily fixed by having the piece re-plated.
Sterling silver is made up of 92.5% pure silver and 7.5% other metals, usually copper, to increase its durability. Sterling silver has a crisper look, often described as a brighter white. However, sterling silver’s shine may dull over time due to tarnishing, especially if exposed to air and moisture. Regular polishing is necessary to maintain its bright look.
Is White Gold Stronger than Sterling Silver?
White gold is stronger than sterling silver, due in part to the strength of the metals alloyed with the gold. It’s more resistant to scratching, bending and general wear and tear, making it a good option for formal, high-end jewelry like engagement rings or wedding bands that are worn daily. In contrast, sterling silver is a relatively soft metal, meaning it’s more prone to scratches and dents. It also tarnishes over time when exposed to sulfur and oxygen in the air, resulting in a dull appearance. While tarnish can be removed with polishing, sterling silver requires more frequent maintenance to keep it looking its best. As such, it’s not ideal for everyday wear if you’re looking for a piece that can withstand constant exposure to the elements. Sterling silver is commonly used for fashion jewelry, casual pieces and by those seeking a more affordable option.
Is White Gold More Expensive than Sterling Silver?
Because of its longevity and status as a precious metal, white gold jewelry tends to be pricier than sterling silver, especially in larger pieces or intricate designs. Its cost is primarily driven by the fluctuating price of gold along with the alloying metals and rhodium plating. This makes sterling silver a popular choice for those seeking the look of precious metal jewelry at a lower price point. While still considered valuable, sterling silver is much more budget-friendly than white gold. This price difference makes sterling silver a great entry-level option for those just starting to build their jewelry collections.
Which Is the Most Hypoallergenic Metal?
The presence of nickel in some white gold alloys can cause skin irritation or allergic reactions in sensitive individuals. If you have a nickel allergy, it’s advisable to seek out white gold jewelry that uses nickel-free alloys or choose an alternative metal like platinum or titanium. Sterling silver typically doesn’t contain nickel, making it a safer option for those with nickel allergies. However, some sterling silver jewelry may have nickel as part of the alloy, so it’s always worth checking if you have known sensitivities. Learn more about hypoallergenic jewelry in this article.
So, which one should you choose? Both white gold and sterling silver are beautiful metals in their own right, so consider what matters most to you when making your decision. Shop white gold and sterling silver jewelry online at Borsheims.com today.
